Natural Diamonds

Buy Loose Diamonds

Shop GIA-certified natural diamonds from Rare Carat, the merchant of record on every order. Once you order, our New York staff inspect every diamond under a microscope, and each one is backed by 30-day returns and 5-star reviews on Google and Trustpilot.

Money-back
guarantee
GIA certified
diamonds
#1 on
Trustpilot
Free insured
shipping

Shop diamonds by shape

Round cut lab diamondsRound
Oval cut lab diamondsOval
Cushion cut man made diamondsCushion
Emerald cut lab created diamondsEmerald
Princess cut lab created diamondsPrincess
Marquise cut lab diamondsMarquise
Shop all shapes
Engagement rings

Create your own engagement ring

Create your custom ring by selecting the diamond and the setting of your choice.

1,894,721 results found
Compare millions of diamonds
to find the best deal

Browse our full catalogue

Where to Buy Diamonds Online: Why Shoppers Choose Rare Carat

If you are deciding where to buy diamonds online, start with who actually sells the diamond. Rare Carat is a direct fine jewelry retailer and the merchant of record on every order. We handle checkout, billing, shipping and customer service ourselves, so there is no middleman between you and your diamond.

Every natural diamond on this page is shipped to our own facilities in New York and New Jersey. Once you place an order, our New York staff inspect the diamond under a microscope, match its laser inscription to the grading certificate and confirm it is exactly what the report says. Only then does it move on to you or into your setting.

We have no retail showroom. That means no store leases and no salesperson commissions built into what you pay, and those savings show up as lower pricing on the loose diamonds you see here. It is one reason we hold 5-star ratings on both Google and Trustpilot and rank as America's highest-rated jewelry brand on Trustpilot.

How to Buy Diamonds Online in Five Steps

Buying a loose diamond online is simple when you follow the same order a jeweler would.

  1. Set your budget first. Decide what you are comfortable spending, then use the price filter so you only see diamonds in that range. Financing options through Affirm, Klarna, Afterpay, PayPal Pay Later and Katapult can spread the cost over time.
  2. Choose a shape. Round diamonds return the most light and remain the classic choice. Elongated shapes such as oval, pear and marquise often look larger than a round of the same carat weight, and fancy shapes usually cost less per carat.
  3. Put cut first. Cut decides how much a diamond sparkles more than any other grade. For round diamonds, aim for an Excellent cut, and look for the Rare Carat Ideal label on stones with our top cut performance.
  4. Balance color and clarity. Once a diamond is set, most people cannot tell neighboring color grades apart. Near-colorless G or H color with an eye-clean VS2 or SI1 clarity is where many buyers find the best value. Use the 360-degree HD video on every diamond to check for visible inclusions before you decide.
  5. Confirm the certificate. Every natural diamond here comes with a grading report. Make sure the carat, color, clarity and cut on the report match the product page, then add the stone to your cart or pair it with a setting.

Natural Diamonds vs Lab-Grown Diamonds

This page shows natural diamonds, formed deep in the earth over billions of years. Lab-grown stones have the same chemical, physical and optical properties, but they are created in a controlled environment and cost far less per carat. Natural diamonds suit buyers who value rarity and tradition, while lab-grown stones suit buyers who want the most size for their budget.

We carry both, with more than 2 million natural and lab-grown diamonds to choose from. Shop lab-grown diamonds or read our full guide to lab-grown diamonds vs real diamonds.

Why GIA Certified Diamonds Matter

A diamond is only worth what its grading report can prove. The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) is the most widely trusted grading lab for natural diamonds, and a GIA report records carat weight, color, clarity, cut grade, measurements and any treatments. Most GIA certified diamonds also carry a laser inscription of the report number on the girdle, which lets you, or any appraiser, tie the physical stone back to its certificate. Our New York team checks that inscription before your diamond ships.

What to Check on Every Diamond Product Page

Each diamond here has its own page, and a few details there tell you more than the headline grades. Start with the measurements: two round diamonds with identical carat weight can face up at different sizes, so a wider diameter means more visible size for your money. Next, look at fluorescence. Faint or medium blue fluorescence rarely affects appearance and can lower the cost, while strong fluorescence is worth a closer look on the video. Then review the proportions, especially table and depth percentages, which shape how bright the stone looks. Finally, open the grading report itself and compare the plotted inclusions with what you see in the 360-degree footage. If anything is unclear, our gemologists can walk you through it before you check out.

Why Buy Loose Diamonds Instead of a Pre-Set Ring

Shopping loose diamonds puts you in control of the stone, which carries most of a ring's cost. You choose the exact stone, review its certificate and 360-degree video, and weigh it against hundreds of other diamonds in the same carat and price range. Then you pair it with a design you love: browse our engagement ring settings and build the ring around the diamond you picked. Starting with the diamond is the surest way to make sure your budget goes into the stone itself.

What Sets the Price of a Diamond

Diamond prices are driven by the 4Cs, and carat weight has the biggest effect. Prices jump at popular weights such as 0.50, 1.00, 1.50 and 2.00 carats, so a 0.90 carat diamond can cost noticeably less than a 1.00 carat stone that looks almost identical once set. Cut, color and clarity then decide where a diamond sits within its weight class. Because we sell direct with no showroom overhead, you can filter certified diamonds by every grade, see exactly what each one costs and pay what each stone is actually worth.

Buy Diamonds With Confidence

Every loose diamond from Rare Carat comes with:

  • 30-day returns (Free extended returns until Jan 15, 2027)
  • Insured shipping on every order
  • Gemologists available to help with anything you need, before or after you buy
  • Flexible payment plans through Affirm, Klarna, Afterpay, PayPal Pay Later and Katapult
  • Free resizing and a lifetime manufacturing warranty when you set your diamond in a Rare Carat ring

Ready to start? Use the filters above to shop loose diamonds by shape, carat, cut, color, clarity and price, and buy your diamond from the jeweler that inspects every stone itself.

FAQ about Natural Diamonds

There are a few different ways to determine if diamonds are real - some of them require lab equipment that you’ll only find in a gemologist’s office. First and foremost, look at the quality and overall appearance. Does the stone look shiny and very sparkly or dull and lifeless? They have an adamantine finish which is hard to replicate in any other simulant material. Next, check for the laser inscription on the girdle. Every diamond sold from Rare Carat will have one. You need magnification to find it, but once you do, match up the inscription with the grading report and lab. Finally, take it to a local graduate gemologist/appraiser. This is a sure thing. They will be able to tell you all the details about your stone and if it’s a real or not.
Get $100 off
Stay up to date with exclusive deals, price alerts, gemologist tips, and more!
Minimum purchase required.
By signing up you agree to our Terms.